Gray two-story house with a covered porch, stone garden path, orange lilies, and mature trees.
Gray two-story house with a covered porch, detached garage, and orange-flowered garden.
Gray two-story house with a covered porch, orange daylilies, and a stone garden path.
Gray two-story house with a white-trimmed porch, detached garage, and orange flowers along the driveway.
Aerial view of a blue-gray two-story house with a covered porch and landscaped garden.
Paved driveway beside a landscaped front yard with a stone path, flower beds, and a large shade tree.
Gray two-story house with a white-columned porch, American flag, and stone garden path.
Covered front porch with white railings, an American flag, and leafy street views.
Home’s covered front porch with gray siding, a glass door marked 23, and a hanging American flag.
Covered porch with gray siding, an American flag by the glass door, and an ornate mailbox.
Paneled wooden front door with lace curtains, a red cross decoration, and a lockbox.
Entryway with a paneled wooden door, blue walls, hardwood floors, and a Historic Irvington sign.
Entryway with teal walls, hardwood floors, and an open wooden door with decorative glass.
Entry foyer with a white staircase, dark built-in shelving, and a wood front door.
Entry hall with a curved hardwood staircase, pale blue walls, and ornate built-in wood cabinetry.
Living room with teal walls, hardwood floors, a white fireplace, and a prominent staircase.
Foyer with a white staircase, hardwood floors, and an ornate built-in wooden cabinet.
Entry hall with a wood staircase, carved doors, and a connecting floral-wallpapered room.
Empty room with teal walls, hardwood floors, olive curtains, and a white-trimmed fireplace.
Empty room with hardwood floors, a decorative fireplace, built-in shelves, and colorful walls.
Empty living room with yellow built-in shelves flanking a white fireplace and polished hardwood floors.
Empty living room with a fireplace, built-in bookshelves, hardwood floors, and a view of the staircase.
Vacant room with polished hardwood floors, teal walls, and an opening to a room with built-in cabinetry.
Empty dining room with floral wallpaper, red wainscoting, hardwood floors, and tall curtained windows.
Dining room with floral wallpaper, red wainscoting, hardwood floors, and a chandelier.
Empty room with floral wallpaper, pink wainscoting, hardwood floors, and a chandelier.
Vacant room with floral wallpaper, red lower walls, hardwood floors, and a brass chandelier.
Kitchen with two-tone cabinetry, black appliances, and a bright window above the sink.
Kitchen with paneled cabinets, a double sink beneath the window, and wood-paneled walls.
Kitchen with cream cabinets, a window over the sink, and wood-paneled walls with built-in shelves.
Wood-paneled kitchen with black appliances, a large refrigerator, and a chandelier.
Small green room with louvered closet doors, a curtained window, and a worn white exterior door.
Room with pale green walls, white louvered closet doors, and a red curtain divider.
Laundry room with a white washer and dryer beneath built-in shelves and a red curtain.
Bathroom with a blue bathtub, floral shower curtain, white toilet, and pedestal sink.
Bathroom with a blue bathtub, floral shower curtain, tiled walls, and white pedestal sink.
Empty living room with a freestanding stove on a brick hearth and glass doors to a tiled patio.
Empty living room with a freestanding stove on a raised brick hearth and curtained French doors.
Empty living room with a green brick fireplace wall, freestanding stove, and built-in shelves.
Empty room with gold-patterned walls, built-in shelving, and a white stove on a tiled hearth.
Room with a cream freestanding stove, mustard brick fireplace wall, and built-in white cabinets.
Wood-paneled sunroom with a glass roof, raised tiled platform, and French doors.
Enclosed sunroom with a glass roof, wood-paneled walls, terracotta tile, and built-in tiled counter seating.
Sunroom with a glass-panel ceiling, wood-paneled walls, and terracotta tile flooring.
Empty yellow room with two curtained windows and wide-plank wood flooring.
Empty room with yellow walls, wood floors, a curtained window, and an open doorway to the stair landing.
Empty room with honey-toned hardwood floors, pale yellow walls, and open wooden doors.
Unfurnished room with mint-green walls, hardwood floors, and ornate curtains framing a bright window.
Unfurnished mint-green room with polished hardwood floors and an open wooden door.
Empty room with reddish-brown walls, a wood plank floor, ceiling fan, and curtained window.
Empty bedroom with floral wallpaper, wood plank flooring, and a ceiling fan.
Empty room with worn wood floors, two curtained windows, and a floral border.
Vacant blue room with floral wall border, wood floors, paneled doors, and a hanging light.
Bathroom with a white clawfoot tub, pedestal sink, and green and lavender walls.
Bathroom with a white freestanding tub, sage cabinetry, marble-patterned tile, and a floral-shaded window.
Unfinished basement utility room with exposed beams, a laundry sink, and water filtration equipment.
Unfinished basement with paint storage shelves, two freezers and a utility sink.
Unfinished basement with exposed beams, freezers, and shelving stocked with paint cans.
Unfinished basement with exposed joists, ductwork, a chest freezer, and refrigerator.
Gray-sided house beside a white double garage, with a paved driveway and leafy trees.
Leafy backyard garden with a stone path, potted plants, hostas, and a white lattice fence beside a gray-sided house.
Backyard patio with irregular stone paving, a white storage shed, raised planters, and mature trees.
Rear of a gray-sided two-story house with a brick chimney, stone patio, and leafy garden.
Rear of gray two-story house with a broad flagstone patio and leafy garden.
Home’s front porch beside a lush garden, with a stone path and white columns.
Blue-sided two-story house with a steep gray roof, mature trees, and a brick-and-iron garden fence.
Aerial view of a blue-gray house with a broad shingled roof among mature leafy trees.
Aerial view of a blue-sided house with a gray roof, largely surrounded by mature trees.
Aerial view of a brick building complex with parking lots and mature trees.
Gray two-story house with a covered porch, stone walkway, and leafy trees surrounding the yard.
Aerial view of a gray house with a broad shingle roof and covered porch, surrounded by mature trees.
Aerial view of a gray two-story house with a covered porch, stone path, and leafy landscaped yard.
Aerial view of a gray two-story house nestled among mature trees, with a covered porch and brick front fence.
Gray-sided house with a steep roof and front porch, surrounded by mature trees.
Aerial view of a gray-roofed house surrounded by mature trees, with a screened porch and driveway.
Aerial view of a gray two-story house with a covered porch amid mature trees.
Aerial view of a gray two-story house with a covered porch, mature trees, and a fenced playground nearby.
Aerial view of a gray-roofed house surrounded by mature trees, stone paths, and landscaped grounds.
Aerial view of a gray-shingled house nestled among mature trees, with a street nearby.
Aerial view of a gray-roofed house with a brick chimney and screened porch, surrounded by mature trees.
VIEW PHOTOS
Courtesy of Circle Real Estate, Annie Caruso Listing Contact:  
$292,305

23 S Downey Avenue

3 Beds 2 Baths 2,366 Sq.Ft. 8,059 Sq.Ft.

Inquire Now

Description

Once featured on the prestigious Irvington Home Tour, this captivating Victorian is a rare opportunity to own a piece of Indianapolis history. Brimming with character and thoughtful updates, this home blends timeless craftsmanship with modern comfort. From the moment you enter the grand foyer, you'll be charmed by soaring ceilings, rich original woodwork, and exquisite built-ins. The main level offers an inviting living room with a decorative fireplace and built-in bookshelves, a spacious formal dining room, a versatile bonus room with an electric fireplace, a full bathroom, a bright sunroom, and modernly appointed kitchen that seamlessly balances vintage charm with contemporary amenities. Upstairs, you'll find three generously sized bedrooms, plus a versatile bonus space that could serve as a fourth bedroom, office, or studio-along with a second full bath and newer windows that offer energy efficiency while preserving the home's historic integrity. Step outside into a lush, fenced backyard oasis filled with mature, low-maintenance perennials-perfect for garden enthusiasts and those who do not love yard work. A detached two-car garage adds convenience to this enchanting property. This lovingly maintained Victorian is more than just a home-it's a lifestyle. With just a few personal touches, you can make it truly your own. Don't miss your chance to fall in love with this Irvington treasure!

Share Property

Location

23 S Downey Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46219

Status

Sold

Date Sold

July 18, 2025
Annie Caruso

Annie Caruso

TITLE

Broker | Associate

PHONE

(317) 869-6858

EMAIL

[email protected]

CONTACT AGENT
Gray two-story house with a covered porch, detached garage, and orange-flowered garden.

360 Virtual Tour

Take a tour of this property

Property Amenities

Interior
Laundry room In Unit, Laundry Closet, Main Level
Fireplace Living Room, Non Functional, Recreation Room
Appliances Dishwasher, Disposal, Electric Oven, Refrigerator, Free-Standing Freezer, Water Heater
Total Bedrooms: 3
Full Bathrooms: 2
Other Interior Features Attic Pull Down Stairs, Built-in Features, Vaulted Ceiling(s), Entrance Foyer, Hardwood Floors, Pantry
Area & Lot
Lot Area 8,059 Sq.Ft.
Living area 2,366 Sq.Ft.
MLS® ID 22045132
Year Built 1901
School District Indianapolis Public Schools
Architecture Styles Victorian
Type Residential
Status Sold
Exterior
Stories 2
Air conditioning Central Air
Heat type Forced Air
Water Source Public
Garage Space 2.0
Parking Detached
Finance
Sales Price $292,305

Similar Listings

For Sale

Red brick home with a two-car garage, landscaped front yard, and concrete driveway.
$470,000

7342 Pymbroke Drive, Fishers, IN 46038

  • 3 BEDS
  • 2 BATHS
  • 2,041 Sq.Ft.

For Sale

Aerial view of a green parcel outlined in red, with scattered trees and nearby residential subdivisions.
$1,795,000

5377 W 1000 N, Mc Cordsville, IN 46055

Coming Soon

Multistory apartment building with tan brick facades, planted balconies, and pedestrians along the sidewalk.
$1,925,000

607 Veterans Way Unit: 302, Carmel, IN 46032

  • 2 BEDS
  • 3 BATHS
  • 2,388 Sq.Ft.
View All

Work With Us

We believe that satisfying the customer is simply the minimum requirement for staying in business. We work constantly to improve our systems, processes, and services to go well beyond the standard level of service provided by most agents.

Contact
Get in Touch
Contact Details

CIRCLE REAL ESTATE

+1 317 643 9911

[email protected]



30 W Main Street

Carmel, IN 46032

CIRCLE Real Estate